The debate surrounding the Heisman Trophy heats up as the Buckeye Talk crew examines the value of a player who significantly impacts his team”s performance compared to a star athlete on a well-rounded roster. This conversation particularly highlights Haynes King, the quarterback for Georgia Tech, who is under scrutiny for his ability to carry a heavy load for his team.
According to Stefan Krajisnik, King has an impressive physical and statistical presence, which raises questions about whether other top quarterbacks could endure the same challenges. “I don”t know how many of them would survive if they were asked to do what Haynes King is doing,” Krajisnik states, noting that King has amassed a remarkable 754 rushing yards and scored 14 rushing touchdowns this season.
Andrew Gillis poses a critical question regarding the value of a player like King, who is crucial to the success of a good team. He wonders, “What do you guys think the value is, whether it”s a lot or a little, when this dude is not only the engine; he”s the carburetor, he”s the windshield wiper fluid, he”s the lights, he”s everything that makes that team go?” This question underscores the complexity of assessing a player”s worth in the Heisman race.
However, Stephen Means provides a counterpoint, suggesting that King”s heavy reliance on running may indicate limitations in his passing ability rather than solely a necessity for the team. “What he”s doing at Georgia Tech is because they need him to do that, but that”s also because it”s what his skill set is,” Means explains. He recalls that two years ago, King threw for 27 touchdowns but also had 16 interceptions, highlighting the dual nature of his contributions.
The podcast”s discussion brings forth an essential dialogue about the true meaning of “valuable” within the context of the Heisman Trophy. As the season progresses, the criteria for this prestigious award remain a topic of passionate debate among fans and analysts alike.
This week”s podcast also touches on other relevant topics, including the impact of team success on Heisman considerations and recent developments surrounding Ohio State football, including a recruitment flip from Florida State involving the son of a former Pittsburgh Steelers linebacker.
