The coaching carousel in college football is gaining momentum, especially as the NFL season nears its conclusion. Amidst this backdrop, speculation has intensified regarding the New York Giants seeking a new head coach following a tumultuous season that warranted a leadership change mid-year. Linked to this vacancy is Marcus Freeman, the head coach of the Notre Dame Fighting Irish, which has sparked considerable debate among analysts and fans alike.
During a recent appearance on “Up & Adams,” former Notre Dame receiver Golden Tate voiced his strong opposition to Freeman considering the Giants position. He emphasized Freeman”s lack of NFL coaching experience and highlighted the challenges associated with the professional landscape, especially for someone rooted in the college game. Tate”s remarks followed reports from NFL Network”s Mike Garafolo that suggested Freeman could be a candidate for the Giants” head coaching job.
Tate, who played for the Giants for two seasons, expressed his concerns directly. “If I am Marcus Freeman, I say “hell to the no” and I stay right there,” he stated. “Stay right there in South Bend, Indiana. You have something amazing.” His argument is grounded in Freeman”s successful tenure at Notre Dame, where he has a record of 43-12 but has never stepped into an NFL coaching role.
Recognizing the stark differences between college and professional football, Tate noted, “If I”m just looking outside, he doesn”t have any background in NFL. NFL, that”s a huge jump, buddy.” He believes that Freeman is in a prime position at Notre Dame and should not risk his career by taking on the Giants, a team struggling with instability and a history of challenges in their coaching transitions.
The Giants are currently in disarray, having recently fired head coach Brian Daboll after a disappointing start to the season. Interim coach Mike Kafka has yet to secure a win since taking over, leading the team to a 2-12 record. In contrast, Tate pointed out that other young coaches finding success this season had prior NFL experience, making them better suited for the challenges of the league.
Freeman led the Fighting Irish to a 10-2 record in 2025, but the season ended controversially with a missed College Football Playoff berth, prompting the program to withdraw from bowl consideration. Tate concluded his segment with an earnest plea to Freeman, saying, “Marcus, please don”t leave us. We”ve had enough heartbreak as Notre Dame people already this year with the whole playoff thing.”
