In the realm of fantasy football, evaluating draft-day decisions is crucial for improvement in upcoming seasons. As we analyze the 2025 season, it is essential to identify both the significant misses and surprises in player performances, particularly among running backs and quarterbacks. This review focuses on the lessons learned to refine our strategies for next year.
Running Backs Review
Kaleb Johnson, Pittsburgh Steelers: Johnson”s ranking was a colossal miss among industry projections, leading many to overlook him as the season progressed. When Najee Harris was sidelined, Johnson was expected to step in without considering the potential contributions of Kenneth Gainwell. The Steelers” decision to retain Gainwell before the NFL draft hinted at possible committee dynamics that many ignored, leading to a disappointing season for Johnson.
Saquon Barkley, Philadelphia Eagles: While numerous running backs have declined after heavy workloads, some have managed to maintain their production levels. Notably, this season marked a downturn for Barkley, coinciding with the Eagles” worst offensive output since 2021. The issues with the offensive line and Barkley”s wear and tear significantly impacted his performance.
Ashton Jeanty, Las Vegas Raiders: Jeanty did not meet the expectations set by even the lowest rankings. Although my projections were relatively close, ranking him as RB8 was overly optimistic given the disappointing environment in Las Vegas. His case serves as a reminder that rookie running backs must show more potential when being drafted among the top picks.
Kenneth Walker, Seattle Seahawks: Despite early optimism about Walker as a featured back, his performance fell short of expectations. The Seahawks” choice to maintain a timeshare limited Walker”s effectiveness, resulting in a frustrating season for fantasy managers.
Rhamondre Stevenson, New England Patriots: Stevenson faced challenges in a timeshare but showed resilience upon returning from injury. His late-season surge demonstrated that even in shared backfields, a player can still find success.
Javonte Williams, Dallas Cowboys: The Cowboys” decision to invest in Williams despite his injury history indicated confidence in his abilities. His performance was bolstered by the team”s commitment, which fantasy managers should have heeded more closely.
Travis Etienne, Jacksonville Jaguars: The uncertainty surrounding the Jaguars” new head coach initially overshadowed Etienne”s potential. However, it became clear that low expectations for him were unwarranted, given his prior impressive seasons.
James Cook, Buffalo Bills: Cook”s performance exceeded projections significantly, showcasing the value of appreciating strong performances rather than questioning their sustainability.
Quarterbacks Review
Jalen Hurts, Philadelphia Eagles: The Eagles” offensive struggles led to the dismissal of their offensive coordinator, impacting Hurts” production. Despite throwing for a career-high in touchdowns, his rushing statistics notably declined, highlighting the risks associated with changes in coaching staff.
Cam Ward, Tennessee Titans: Ward”s rookie season was lackluster, marked by few standout performances and a lack of rushing contributions. The coaching staff”s inability to leverage his potential was a significant misstep.
Trevor Lawrence, Jacksonville Jaguars: In contrast to Ward, Lawrence thrived with a strong supporting cast, demonstrating that quality coaching and effective weaponry can unlock a quarterback”s potential.
Drake Maye, New England Patriots: Maye surprised many with his breakout performance, although concerns about his supporting cast lingered. His ability to elevate his team”s play was reminiscent of past greats, illustrating the impact of quarterback talent on overall team success.
In summary, the 2025 fantasy football season provided a wealth of insights into player evaluations and draft strategies. Adapting to the evolving landscape of the league will be essential as we prepare for future seasons.
