The Dallas Cowboys face a potential offseason dilemma regarding their standout kicker, Brandon Aubrey, who is poised to become a restricted free agent. Aubrey”s exceptional kicking ability has made him one of the most valuable assets in the NFL, but the Cowboys must act quickly to secure his services before free agency opens on March 11.
If the Cowboys fail to finalize a long-term contract with Aubrey, they will need to issue a one-year restricted free agent tender, which could range from various levels of compensation based on the type of tender they select. The options include a first-round tender valued at $8.02 million, a second-round tender at $5.81 million, and a right-of-refusal tender at $3.55 million. If the Cowboys utilize any of these tenders, other teams can submit offers, and the Cowboys would retain the right to match any bid. A first-round tender could mean significant compensation if Aubrey signs elsewhere, while a second-round tender would yield a second-round pick for Dallas if he departs.
Aubrey has already set the record for the most field goals of 60 yards or more in a single season, emphasizing his status as a premier kicker in the league. His performance is particularly notable indoors, where he has converted nearly 94% of his field goal attempts throughout his career, compared to a lower percentage in outdoor stadiums. This unique skill set makes him an attractive target for teams in need of a reliable kicker.
Potential Suitors for Aubrey
Several NFL teams are well-positioned to pursue Aubrey if he becomes available, particularly those with indoor stadiums that would maximize his kicking potential. Here are four franchises that could make a play for the talented kicker:
Los Angeles Rams
The Los Angeles Rams struggled with their kicking game last season, cycling through multiple kickers without finding a reliable option. With Joshua Karty and Harrison Mevis failing to deliver consistent performances, the Rams could benefit greatly from Aubrey”s ability to connect on long-range attempts. Under head coach Sean McVay, the Rams have not had a kicker with Aubrey”s exceptional range, and his presence could have altered the outcome of several close games last season.
Atlanta Falcons
The Atlanta Falcons experienced a tumultuous kicking situation in 2025, leading to a series of missed opportunities that cost them potential victories. With several kickers failing to perform, acquiring Aubrey could provide the stability they desperately need. A new head coach is set to lead the Falcons, and bringing in a proven kicker like Aubrey would be a wise decision as they aim to improve their performance in the coming season.
New York Giants
In New York, the Giants have been unable to find consistency in their kicking game, using four different kickers last season. With head coach John Harbaugh now at the helm, he is likely to prioritize rectifying this issue. The Giants currently have Graham Gano, but given his age and injury history, Harbaugh might seek to secure Aubrey”s services to bolster the team”s chances.
Arizona Cardinals
Lastly, the Arizona Cardinals faced difficulties with their kicker last season, resulting in several missed opportunities in close games. Although the potential cost of acquiring Aubrey might be a consideration for the Cardinals, his ability to make crucial kicks could make a significant difference for the team. The Cardinals need reliable scoring options, especially in tight matchups, and Aubrey would provide that edge.
As the offseason approaches, the pressure is mounting on the Cowboys to retain Aubrey. With multiple teams likely to pursue him, Dallas must act decisively to keep one of the best kickers in the game.
